Both the style of music uses very
similar theoretical terminology, however the approach and the actual meaning of
it is quite different. In this topic, we will discuss about the terms, its
significance and the relationship between the two styles.
Notes
There are 12 notes in music as we know
it. In Hindustani, these 12 notes are called ‘‘Swaras’’. Now, the 12 notes are
divided into two. In western music, the division is known as Natural and
Accidental notes whereas in Hindustani, Swaras are divided as Shudh Swaras and
Vikrit Swaras. There are 7 natural and 5 accidental notes and similarly, in Hindustani
music there are 7 Shudh Swaras and 5 Vikrit Swaras. However, Natural notes are
not the same as Shudh Swaras and Accidental notes are not the same as Vikrit
Swaras.
Natural notes in western music are all
the white keys on a piano, which are A, B, C, D, E, F, G. The accidental notes
are referred to the sharp and flat notes which are the black keys on the piano.
Shudh swaras are referred to the notes of any major scale, any change in the
note in the major scale is due to the introduction of Vikrit Swaras.
Taking best of both
Both styles have a theory that best
suits their need and necessity. Hindustani students do a lot of Alankaar
practice which goes something like " Sa Re Ga, Re Ga Ma, Ga Ma Pa…".
Western vocal students can do the same exercise as "Do Re Mi, Re Mi Fa, Mi
Fa So…".
Now if you know your chords, you will
know that the major and minor chord is formed of three notes. For example ; C
major scale is made up of C E G. In Hindustani the same major scale will be
formed by Sa Ga Pa, so when you are singling over C major chord, you should not
sing komal ga with it. However you have to start your Sargam starting in C.
Conclusion
So, from above, you can come to conclusion
that both Hindustani and Western has same number of notes. But western tells
you the pitch through its given notes but Hindustani music theory depends on
the Swaras and the pitch is decided later. The basic difference is the
influence of the region, Hindustani takes styles from their traditional culture
whereas the Western takes up influences from the European countries.
However, the notes involved are quite similar, only the execution of it is different. So
there is not one style which is better, they are just influenced from two
different parts of the world and thus can be heard in them. So, as a musician
you should research as much as you can on both the styles and use the favourite
techniques from both the styles.
BlueTimbre is a unique Music Company that provides Music Education and Recording Studio services. BlueTimbre also works with schools to provide end-to-end Music Education solutions for schools.
The BlueTimbre team comes with decades of cumulative experience in running Structured Businesses, Music Curriculum Development, Music Education and Performance.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete